The Blog · November 13, 2026

Marketplace Math: What a Seller Actually Keeps From a $100 Sale

A hundred dollars changes hands and the seller never sees all of it. On Etsy the cut is $9.95; on Shopify and WooCommerce it is $3.20; on Squarespace it depends on which plan you picked. The published fee schedules, added up.

Every platform in our E-commerce Platforms rankings can take a $100 order. What differs is how much of that $100 reaches the seller, and the answer is never a single number on any pricing page. So this post does the same sum four times: one $100 item, sold in the US, paid by card online, no shipping, no sales tax in the fee base, no advertising. The four platforms are Shopify (Veridata Score 89), WooCommerce (84), Etsy (82) and Squarespace (80).

Etsy: three fees on every sale

Etsy charges at three separate points on a single sale. The published US rates are a $0.20 listing fee per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus any shipping charged, and 3% plus $0.25 in payment processing. On a $100 sale with no shipping, that is $0.20 plus $6.50 plus $3.25 — $9.95 in fees, and the seller keeps $90.05.

Then there is the fourth fee, the one that only fires sometimes. If the buyer arrived through an Offsite Ad, Etsy charges an additional 12% for shops that made under $10,000 in the previous year, and 15% once they pass it. On the same $100 sale, that is another $12 or $15, and the seller keeps $78.05 or $75.05. A seller who never runs ads never pays it. Etsy’s review puts the trade plainly: the traffic is the whole product, and the stack is the price of it.

Shopify: the cheapest per-sale cut, plus rent

Shopify takes the smallest bite per sale of the four, and charges rent for the privilege. Basic costs $39 a month billed monthly, or $29 a month billed yearly, and the online card rate on Basic through Shopify Payments is 2.9% plus 30 cents. On a $100 sale that is $3.20, and the seller keeps $96.80 before the plan is counted. Count the plan and the number moves: at ten $100 sales a month, the $39 plan adds $3.90 to every sale, and the real keep is $92.90.

One choice makes the per-sale number worse. Take payments through a third-party gateway instead of Shopify Payments, and Shopify adds its own fee on top: 2% on Basic. On a $100 sale that is another $2.00, for a total of $5.20, and the seller keeps $94.80.

Squarespace: the 3% that decides the plan

Squarespace is the one platform where the per-sale keep depends on which plan the seller picked. Its Business plan costs $23 a month billed annually, or $33 month to month, and carries a 3% transaction fee on every sale. Its Commerce Basic plan costs $28 a month billed annually and charges no transaction fee. Processing is the same on both: 2.9% plus 30 cents through Stripe or PayPal in the US. On a $100 sale, Business costs $3.00 in platform fees plus $3.20 in processing — $6.20, and the seller keeps $93.80. On Commerce Basic, it costs $3.20 and nothing to the platform — the seller keeps $96.80. The $5-a-month upgrade saves 3% of every sale, so it pays for itself once monthly sales pass about $167.

WooCommerce: the platform takes nothing — the processor still does

WooCommerce is the odd one out because its price is not a price at all. The core plugin is free and open-source, and WooCommerce itself charges no transaction fee on any sale. What the seller still pays is the processor: WooCommerce Payments charges 2.9% plus 30 cents per transaction for US domestic cards. On a $100 sale, that is $3.20, and the seller keeps $96.80 — tied with Shopify Basic for the best per-sale keep, with no monthly platform fee attached. The catch is not a fee; it is a job. The seller pays for the hosting and handles the updates, backups, and security the hosted platforms include in their rent — the review calls the seller the IT department.

The same $100, four keeps

Side by side, before any monthly plan is counted: Shopify Basic keeps $96.80, WooCommerce keeps $96.80, Squarespace keeps $96.80 on Commerce Basic and $93.80 on Business, and Etsy keeps $90.05 — or $78.05 if the sale came from an Offsite Ad at the 12% rate. The spread between the best and worst ordinary sale is $6.75, on $10,000 of monthly sales, that is $675 a month. Rent is the part the per-sale table hides: Shopify’s $39 a month and Squarespace’s $23 to $28 a month are fixed, so they punish a slow month and vanish into a busy one, while Etsy charges no monthly fee at all.

What the scores say

The four platforms sit within nine points of each other — Shopify 89, WooCommerce 84, Etsy 82, Squarespace 80 — Shopify leads because the per-sale keep is the best in the category and the rent buys a checkout shoppers already trust. WooCommerce trails it by five points because the same keep comes with the maintenance job attached. Etsy sits third despite the highest fees, because the fee stack buys something none of the others sell: buyers who arrived looking for handmade goods. Squarespace trails at 80 because the design is the best in the category, but the 3% fee on the entry commerce tier taxes the sellers least able to absorb it. None of the four hides its fees; the difference is how many places the fee is charged.

These scores are a snapshot of what the companies publish today, checked November 13, 2026. When a company changes what it publishes — a rate repriced, a plan renamed, a fee finally printed on the pricing page — we re-check it against the same rubric, and its score moves with the evidence. The full E-commerce Platforms rankings are the place to watch it change.

← Back to the blog · November 13, 2026